Caring vs Controlling Parents

EQI.org Home | Main Page on Caring and Control | Main Page on Caring | Emotionally Abusive Parents

Caring vs. Controlling Parents

A formal study has shown that parents who are "neglectful and controlling" are damaging their children's mental health. This is, by the way, what we have been saying for years here at EQI.org. But now formal academic research is supporting our position.

Here is one of the most important findings

Teenage girls were six times more likely to suffer from depressive disorders than those in the ‘optimum parenting’ group, where parents are perceived as being caring but not controlling.

Note that this study was not even trying to identify abusive parents, simply neglectful. So what if a study could identify the emotionally abusive parents? Our guess that it would prove that the children and teens from such parents are something like 100 times more likely to later be depressed, self-harming and suicidal.

Here is one article about the study.

Neglectful and controlling parents linked to mental health problems in children

Children’s perception of how they are parented is a major predictor of whether they will develop mental health problems as teenager, according to research by the University of Glasgow and the Medical Research Council.

Data from almost 1,700 children living in the West of Scotland was analysed by researchers at the College of Medical, Veterinary and Life Sciences and the MRC Social & Public Health Sciences Unit (SPHSU).

It revealed that three per cent of 11 year-old children felt both neglected and controlled by their parents. When the children were tested at age 15, this group were much more likely to have developed psychiatric problems.

Children were grouped according to ‘parenting style’, with the study revealing that the ‘neglected and controlled’ group were more than twice as likely to develop psychiatric disorders. These included anxiety disorders such as obsessive-compulsive disorder, depression and behavioural disorders.

Conduct disorders such as antisocial and violent behaviour and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) were also much more prominent in this group. Teenage girls were six times more likely to suffer from depressive disorders than those in the ‘optimum parenting’ group, where parents are perceived as being caring but not controlling.

Parenting style was assessed using a questionnaire, taking into account the extent to which the children felt loved, allowed to make their own decisions, molly-coddled or supported, amongst other factors. At age 15, psychiatric data was collected by computerised interview.

Robert Young, of the SPHSU, said:

“It is important that we do not trivialise children’s perceptions of parenting, particularly having seen in this study how early feelings about parenting, map onto children’s future mental health and psychological wellbeing. We now need to establish whether the effects are caused by the perception of neglect, actual neglect, or some combination of both.”

Co-author, Dr Helen Minnis, of the University’s School of Medicine, added:

“It is remarkable that despite the wide range of parenting styles reported in the study; the majority of children’s experience of parenting is ‘good enough’, and less than perfect parenting is not associated with major psychiatric problems during adolescence. That said, it seems that children with better perceived parental relationships have fewer psychiatric problems as teenagers.”

Professor Chris Kennard, Chairman of the MRC’s Neuroscience and Mental Health Board, said:

“Whilst only three per cent of children reported the neglectful and controlling parenting which was associated with increased psychiatric disorders, when the implications are expanded this equates to a large number of children nationwide. We must also consider the possibility that developing disorders in childhood increases the risk of more serious problems in adulthood, both for the individual and for society in general. A core part of the MRC’s strategy focuses on mental health, and this study gives clear indications of the importance of the home environment in maintaining mental wellbeing.”

MRC Press Office
Phone: 020 7395 2345
Out of hours phone: 07818 428 297
Email: press.office@headoffice.mrc.ac.uk

The paper ‘Children’s perceptions of parental emotional neglect and control and psychopathology’ by Young, Lennie and Minnis was published on March 24 in the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. It is available online at http://doi.wiley.com/10.1111/j.1469-7610.2011.02390.x

Details of Parental Bonding Instrument (PBI) method

The measure of perceived parental style used in the study is the brief current form of the Parental Bonding Instrument. This is an 8-item questionnaire which asks children about the relationship they have with their parents, e.g. ‘My parents are loving’ or ‘My parents try to control everything I do’ or ‘My parents understand my problems and worries’, with three options ‘almost always’, ‘sometimes’ and ‘never’.

Analysis of the responses from 2583 11-year old children identified four groups of perceived parenting. 20% could be describe as ‘optimal’ (loving and non-controlling); 54% as typical; 23% ‘moderate’ (somewhat tougher, but still loving) and 3% as ‘neglectful and controlling’ (unloving and highly controlling) parenting.

Details of Voice-DISC assessment

Psychiatric assessment used a computerised version of the Diagnostic Interview Schedule for Children and Adolescence. This is a standard method of assessment compatible with the American Psychiatric Associations, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual IV. The assessment takes between 30-90 minutes, depending on the seriousness of any psychiatric problems, with qualified psychiatric staff ‘on-hand’. Young people answer a series of questions typically used in a psychiatric assessment. For example, thoughts about suicide and arson, and delusions and hallucinations are considered.

EQI.org Home Page

Other EQI.org Topics:

Search EQI.org | Support EQI.org

Online Consulting, Counseling Coaching from EQI.org